Order Assignments Now Get Upto 50% Off “Let’s fight, Help and Win” UPTO 50% OFF due to COVID-19 break down Order Now
Search

Woolworths v Kelly

Question :

Woolworths supermarket is a big chain in Australia that majorly deals in groceries. They have many chains in different locations in Australia. The case of Woolworth v Kelly deals with the adequacy of the consideration. This is the case were the worker of the company claims the amount of pension and other payments such as annuity.

  • What are the essentials of a valid contract?
  • What was the case of Woolworth v Kelly about?
  • What do you mean by adequacy of consideration with reference to Woolworths v Kelly.
Answer :

Woolworths Supermarket

Woolworths is chain of Australian Supermarket which was founded in the year 1924. it specialises in groceries but also sells many other items like health & beauty products, stationery, magazines, household products, etc.

Contract Law of Australia

The contract law of Australia is not a codified legislation rather it is overseen by the courts and is a common law. The main feature of the contract law is that there is freedom of contract which means that the parties are free to strike what ever bargain they wants to choose. There are five essentials of the valid contract under the Australian contract law which includes an agreement between the parties but not the unilateral contract then consideration is also present which means a requirement of bargain or the supply of service, property or money but does not involve undertaking any particular act in the exchange of anything. Third essential is capacity to enter into legal relations and fourth is intention of the parties to enter into legal relations. If any of the element is not present then it is meant that the agreement is not enforceable as the contract under the law. The law of contract to have binding force upon the parties must fulfil all the given essential conditions to the contract. Non compliance with any of the essential will make the contract invalid and it will not be enforced by the law.

Take Law Assignment Help

Consideration can be anything which is stipulated and is legal by a promiser. The consideration must have some value in the eyes of Law and it must be in existence.

Adequacy of Consideration means that to have the contract lawfully valid it is important that there exist some consideration at a fair value that can either be equivalent to or proportional to the offer made by the offeror.

have a question or Need assistance
CALL US +1 2139295632

Facts

Sir Theo Kelly was a clerk at Woolworths Limited in 1928 and in 1940 he grabbed the position of leadership in a very less time. At the time of his retirement, the control of the company was passed to other directors who changed the policies of the company. A dispute arose which relates to the pension entitlement. Kelly was entitled to the amount of pension and also quarterly payments or annuity. He ordered the company and made declarations to claim the money from the company. This resulted in filing an appeal by the company to the court to claim the amount due from the company.

Legal Issues

  • Whether Kelly is entitle to claim pension and annuity?
  • Whether the adequacy of the consideration be determined?

Decision

It was held by the court that the amount of consideration varies in different situation and it cant easily be calculated. The amount may seems inadequate to the court but it may be different for the person claiming it. The claimant may have value for consideration or may also have sentimental reasons. It gets impossible for the court to indulge in such evaluation and promises that were made between the parties. The court further said that if these evaluations had to be made, they must be made by the lawyers trained for the same. This will further increase the disputes between the parties in case of non-agreement.

You may like

Porter's five forces on Kitkat

The court also explained that there is generally no need for the enquiry into adequacy of the consideration. The doctrine of considerations needs that there must be something given in return for the promise so that the contract can be made binding and enforceable by the law.

Criticism of the Judgement

It is generally seen that different people places different values for the things and the judiciary are not trained in the subject economics and other things which helps them to decide on such issues. Different judges may offer different judgement on this same issues which may result in uncertainty.

Download Full Sample
Cite This Work To export references to this sample, select the desired referencing style below:
Global Assignment Help. (2021). . Retrieved from: https://www.globalassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/woolworths-v-kelly
Copy to Clipboard
Copy to Clipboard
Global Assignment Help (2021) [Online]. Retrieved from: https://www.globalassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/woolworths-v-kelly
Copy to Clipboard
Global Assignment Help. ' ' (Global Assignment Help, 2021)https://www.globalassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/woolworths-v-kelly
Copy to Clipboard
Global Assignment Help. [Internet]. Global Assignment Help.(2021), Retrieved from: https://www.globalassignmenthelp.com/free-samples/woolworths-v-kelly
Copy to Clipboard

When it comes to providing case study help, our writers know what to do. We have provided Nike case study help to many students globally and conducted many Zara case study writing for them. Whether you need help with IKEA strategic case study & analysis or McDonald’s Pestle & Swot analysis, you can count on our professionals for the best solutions. They have a knack for writing case studies on various brands.

Boost Grades & Leave Stress

Share Your Requirements Now for Customized Solutions.

Lowest Price
USD6.84

Delivered on-time or your money back

100+ Qualified Writers

For Best Case Study Assignment Help

  • Tina Mosbey
    1200 - Completed Orders
    Tina Mosbey View Profile Ph.D in Computer Science USA Hire Me
  • Robert Jackson
    1321 - Completed Orders
    Robert Jackson View Profile Master's in International Law USA Hire Me
  • Emma Radcliff
    1231 - Completed Orders
    Emma Radcliff View Profile Graduate in Textile Engineering Australia Hire Me
  • Tim Cruise
    1321 - Completed Orders
    Tim Cruise View Profile Graduate in Petroleum Engineering Australia Hire Me
View All Writers
FREE Tools

To Make Your Work Original

  • Plagiarism Checker

    Check your work against plagiarism & get a free Turnitin report!

    Check Plagiarism
  • Reference Generator

    Get citations & references in your document in the desired style!

    Generate References
? Help
Whatsapp